Pool Removal for Blue Ash Backyards: Filled In or Hauled Away Entirely

Why homeowners around Cincinnati take out a pool

The reasons tend to repeat. Kids grew up and moved out. A concrete pool needs resurfacing, or a vinyl liner has torn and the steel walls behind it are rusting. A new owner bought the house for the lot and the school district, not the pool. Someone wants a bigger patio, a garage or an addition where the water used to be.

There is also the slope. Many yards in the hill neighborhoods and older suburbs were never quite flat, and a pool built into a grade can start to shift as the soil behind it moves. Cracks in the deck, a tilted coping line or water that will not hold are all signs that a pool may be nearing the end, whatever its age.

Partial removal versus full removal

There are two broad ways to make a pool disappear, and the cheaper one is not always the smart one. Partial removal, often called a fill-in or abandonment, leaves most of the shell in the ground. Full removal takes the entire shell out and replaces it with fill placed as engineered fill.

• Partial removal: the top of the walls and the coping are broken out, the floor is punched through so water can drain, and the hole is filled and compacted. Less hauling and less work.
• Full removal: every piece of concrete, fiberglass, steel and liner is hauled off, and the hole is backfilled with engineered fill compacted in layers. More work, but nothing is left buried.
• Partial removal can show up later in a home inspection or a survey and may limit what can be built on that spot.
• Full removal is usually preferred by buyers, lenders and builders who want to put a structure there someday.

How a partial removal is usually done

A fill-in still takes real equipment and a careful sequence. Skipping the drainage step is the most common mistake, and it is the one that leaves a bathtub of trapped water underground.

1. Drain the pool and disconnect power, gas and plumbing to the equipment.
2. Remove the pump, filter, heater, ladders, rails, diving board and lights.
3. Break out the deck around the pool and the upper part of the walls, dropping the rubble into the deep end or hauling it off.
4. Punch or break several large holes through the floor so water can pass through the bottom.
5. Bring in fill and spread it in layers, compacting each one before the next goes in.
6. Finish with topsoil, grade it to shed water, and seed or sod.

How a full removal is usually done

A full haul-out turns the pool back into a plain excavation, and then fills it properly. It takes more truck trips and a larger machine, but the result is a yard with nothing hidden in it.

1. Drain the pool and make every utility line safe.
2. Break the shell into manageable pieces with a hydraulic breaker on an excavator, or cut it up if it is fiberglass.
3. Pull out all concrete, rebar, steel wall panels, liner and plumbing.
4. Haul concrete to a recycler and metal to a scrap yard; the rest goes to a landfill.
5. Backfill with engineered fill placed and compacted in layers, with testing if the city or a future builder asks for it.
6. Cap the area with topsoil and shape the grade so water moves away from the house.

Concrete, fiberglass and vinyl-liner pools come out differently

Gunite and poured concrete pools are the heaviest job. The walls are thick and reinforced with steel, so breaking them takes a hydraulic hammer and time, and the rubble is substantial. Most of that concrete can be crushed and recycled.

Fiberglass pools are one-piece shells. They are usually cut into sections with a saw and lifted out, and the material goes to a landfill because there is no common recycling path for it. Vinyl-liner pools have a liner over steel, aluminum or polymer walls with a sand or grout floor; the liner tears out quickly, the wall panels go for scrap, and the floor is broken or removed. Above-ground pools are the lightest work of all and are covered further down.

Draining the pool, and where the water goes

A full pool holds a large volume of water, and where it is pumped matters. Many cities and sewer districts have rules about discharging pool water, especially water that still carries chlorine or salt, into storm drains that feed local creeks and eventually Mill Creek or the Ohio River. Some want it sent to the sanitary sewer through a cleanout, others want it dechlorinated first. Ask the local public works office or sewer district before pumping.

On sloped lots, pumping a pool straight onto the lawn can saturate the hillside and set clay moving, or flood the neighbor's basement downhill. A slow, directed discharge is safer. Never fully drain a concrete pool in a high water table and leave it empty, because groundwater pressure can lift the shell.

Fill and compaction decide whether the yard settles

The fill is the part you live with long after the contractor is gone. Clay soils around Southwest Ohio hold water, swell when wet and shrink in dry summers, and freeze-thaw cycles work on anything loose. If a pool is filled by dumping dirt in all at once, the yard will keep settling for years and may pond after every rain.

Good fill goes in in layers, each one run over by a compactor or a roller before the next is added. Clean granular material or a suitable soil is used in the body of the hole, with topsoil only at the surface where grass will grow. Rubble and broken concrete left in a fill-in should be spread and buried well below the surface, not stacked in one corner. If a future building is likely, ask whether compaction testing will be done and documented.

Electrical, gas and plumbing to the pool

Pools are tied into the house in more ways than most owners realize. There is usually a dedicated circuit for the pump and lights, sometimes a gas line to a heater, a water fill line and the plumbing between the skimmers, main drain, returns and equipment pad.

An electrician should disconnect the pool circuits at the panel and remove or terminate the wiring so nothing is left live in the ground. If a heater runs on natural gas or propane, a plumber or the gas company closes and seals that line. Skimmer and return lines are cut and capped or removed with the shell. As with any digging, call OHIO811 first so buried utility lines around the yard are marked.

Decking, equipment, fencing and the spa

The pool is rarely the only thing coming out. Concrete or stamped decking, coping stones, a pool house, an equipment pad and the safety fence around the yard may all be part of the job. Pumps, filters and heaters are mostly metal and usually go for scrap. A wood deck around an above-ground pool comes apart much like any other deck, which the garage and shed demolition page discusses.

If the surrounding concrete patio stays, the edge where the pool deck meets it should be saw-cut clean; that work and wider patio removal are covered on the concrete removal page. A built-in spa attached to the pool usually comes out with it, sharing the same plumbing and electrical shutoffs.

Permits, inspections and disclosure to a future buyer

Many cities and townships require a permit to remove or fill in a pool, and some send an inspector to look at the drainage holes or the open excavation before fill goes in. One call to the local permit office answers which of those steps your property faces. File away the signed-off permit, any inspection report and a written note from the contractor naming the fill material.

When you sell, expect a buyer or an inspector to ask whether a pool was ever on the property and how it was removed. Being able to hand over that paperwork, especially for a full removal, answers the question quickly. Homeowner associations may have their own rules about work hours and how the yard has to look afterward.

Above-ground pools are a smaller job

An above-ground pool can often be drained and taken down in a day. The liner is cut out, the top rails and uprights unbolted, and the steel or resin wall rolled up or cut for scrap. What is left is a ring of sand or a cove of packed soil, plus any deck built around the pool.

The ground under an above-ground pool is usually flat and compacted, but grass will not have grown there in years. Raking out the sand, loosening the soil and adding topsoil before seeding gives the lawn a fair start.

What you can build on the spot later, and what drives the cost

After a full removal with documented compaction, the area can usually support a patio, a garden, a shed or, with an engineer's input, an addition or garage. After a partial removal, a lawn or garden is the safe use; anything heavier should be checked by a geotechnical or structural engineer first. The cost depends on pool type and size, partial or full removal, how far a machine and trucks have to travel through the yard, deck and equipment removal, fill volume and type, disposal and the permit steps. The contractor prices it after seeing the yard.

For local conditions, the Mason and West Chester pages describe the subdivisions where backyard pools are common. Use the contact page to share a photo of the pool and your address, and we'll route it to a contractor nearby for a site visit.

Pool Removal for Blue Ash Backyards — common questions

Related work

Across the metro